A jury decided on Thursday that Leroy Johnson should instead serve life in prison without parole.
In August, the same jury found him guilty of two counts of first-degree murder for killing Gary and Sandra De Bartolo in 2009.
RELATED: Man found guilty in 2009 murder of a Kerman couple
Prosecutors had argued the crime was so brutal he deserved the death penalty.
Defense attorneys brought up Johnson's troubled childhood and his mental health struggles.